Could eating insects be illegal?

ant_writing.pngIn the vast majority of countries around the world, entomophagy is commonplace. It’s estimated that two billion people regularly eat edible insects: it’s really Europe and North America where you’ll find obstacles, both legal and cultural.

An international food standards body does exist; a joint project between the UN and the World Health Organisation. But the ‘Codex Alimentarius’, as it’s called, is really just a guide for countries to refer to – and that may be a good thing, perhaps, given that insects are currently only included in the Codex as ‘impurities’!

IMG_1454_w960.jpg

Casu marzu. Photo: Nordic Food Lab, licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0

North America

In the United States, FDA regulations cover the amount of accidental insect bits you can get away with in foodstuffs. These rules are the source of many hysterical headlines - “Maggots in your Mushrooms!” and so on – but what about rules for intentional bugs?

When asked the FDA said that insects are “considered food if they are to be used for food or as components of food”. The usual standards around cleanliness, labelling and transportation are required, but on the whole it seems to be a pretty permissive attitude, in contrast to Europe (below). One exception is ‘wildcrafted’ or foraged insects, which cannot be sold as food for fear of pesticide contamination.

worm_looking_back.png

Canada uses the idea of ‘Novel Foods’ to evaluate any new products on the market. This is usually products that come from biotechnology, such as genetically modified or lab-grown food, which requires assessment and approval before being sold for consumption. Food with a “long history of human consumption” are assumed not to pose a risk, but as in the EU, producers must prove that this is the case.

Europe

There are lots of laws and regulations governing what can be sold as food. In the EU, edible insects are not recognised in these existing laws – so technically, they’re not allowed, but member states had a lot of ‘wriggle room’ in what they actually tolerated. Now though, that is set to change.

The new EU regulations, announced in 2015 and rolling out in 2016, aim to end this confusion. The European Food Safety Authority gave its long-awaited opinion, suggesting that insects could be safe, but recommending more research to be sure. The ‘Novel Foods’ regulations are now going to control the sale of insects for human consumption.  ‘Novel Foods’ are, the EU says, ingredients which haven’t been consumed ‘to a significant degree’ in the EU prior to 1997. These will include insects.

Technically, edible were not allowed but EU member states had a lot of ‘wriggle room’

These Novel Food rules are quite strict. Every insect has to be assessed, at the cost to the hopeful producer of several thousand pounds. So basically, unless a producer can prove the insect was widely eaten before 1997, they’ll have to pay for the registration and hope they get approval before starting to sell their product.

One contentious case might be casu marzu – a Sicilian cheese containing live maggots. This cheese and its many other regional variations has been consumed around southern Europe for many generations – but its sale is now illegal. Can producers prove it is ‘traditional’? The next few years, it seems, will be crucial in establishing the future popularity of edible insects in Europe.

Vil regeringen langt om længe tillade spiselige insekter?

Vil regeringen langt om længe tillade spiselige insekter?

I mandags var miljø- og fødevareminister Esben Lunde Larsen på besøg til en temadag på Heimdal Entofarm. Formålet var at få ministeren i tale om, hvordan insekter kan være en del af fremtidens landbrug i Danmark - og få ham og hans ministerium til at bløde lidt op på lovgivningsfronten.

 Dig even deeper →

Legalised in Switzerland, banned in Iceland – edible insects in Europe

Legalised in Switzerland, banned in Iceland – edible insects in Europe

While the appetite for edible bugs increases, and start-ups for cricket farms and new products appear regularly, it’s getting to a bit of a crunch point legally. Insects still inhabit a legal grey area, and it remains to be seen how new European Union rules will play out.

For more detail on the situation within the EU see our article Ban them or boost them! The EU’s struggle with edible insects. Yet not all countries in Europe are in the EU, and recently two non-EU states took very different paths: in Switzerland a programme of legalisation saw more than ten species given the stamp of approval; in Iceland the opposite happened.

 Dig even deeper →

Ban them or boost them? The EU's struggle with edible insects

Ban them or boost them? The EU's struggle with edible insects

The ‘future food’ is here! But it’s for display purposes only… Passing through Milan a few months ago, BUGSfeed editor Ben Kempas went on a mission to eat some insects at the gigantic Expo Milan. This vast exhibition was themed on ‘Feeding the Planet’ – so naturally, edible insects would be available, given all the recent hype about them?

Well, no. You can read Ben’s account of the day here, but the brief version is that he traipsed around this huge exhibition all day without ever getting to lay his hands on a real, consumable bug. To make it worse, he did find them – crunchy grasshoppers, tinned crickets, you name it – but they were sealed off behind glass. Because in Italy, bizarrely, it is not yet legal to serve edible insect products. And yet in other EU countries like Belgium, the situation is quite different. So what’s really going on in Europe?

 Dig even deeper →

My search for insects that would feed the world (2)

My search for insects that would feed the world (2)

Continued from part one, in which I found edible insects in the Future Food District and the Supermarket of the Future but was unable to break the glass that securely locked them away.

I kept roaming the vast Expo area in Milan – all those impressive national pavilions showing how the respective countries were “feeding the planet”, as the Universal Exhibition’s theme suggested. Yet all the nations that, as we’re learning here on BUGSfeed, regularly eat insects (say, Mexico, Uganda or Japan) – they had somehow decided to hide to the world the fact that they do.

 Dig even deeper →

More on Canada

Insect City Utopia: Inside the 'Cricket Reactor'

Jakub Dzamba did not stop at a consumer-friendly countertop farm, but has imagined whole urban landscapes that have the mass production of edible insects built in to their fabric, with heat, warmth, waste and sustainability all addressed. As is often the case with new design and architecture, it's feels simultaneously like far-fetched science fiction, and something that's just around the corner. More →

More on United States Canada

North America's entomophagists are teaming up

For the North American Edible Insects Coalition (NAEIC), the tide is turning: The era of ‘Gross, bugs!’ is giving way to curiosity and enthusiasm. It’s a critical time in this fast-growing industry. More →

More on Europe

Fact check: Are insects better for you than meat?

There’s a big hype around edible insects: low in fat and high in nutrients, they're going to revolutionise food on a global scale! Is it true? BUGSfeed went fact–finding. More →

More on Legal Situation

Put down that bug! – Allergies and edible insects

I’m a big advocate of edible insects. When I started down this path, people weren’t willing to take the leap. Now, I have to stop them before their first bite – because it turns out you can actually be allergic to insects. What a disaster! More →

More on Legal Situation casu marzu

Cheese Fly Larva – the earthworm of cheese-making

It’s not just the Sardinians' Casu Marzu: English Stilton was once ‘wormy’ - and people loved it! More →

More on casu marzu

TEDx: from maggots in cheese to a food revolution

"Insects have to be the key to reflect on our capacity to embrace food diversity and knowledge that come from a different country." – Roberto Flore More →

More on casu marzu

Casu marzu ice cream

Would you like some ice cream? And would you mind if it contained some maggots? More →